The New York Mets are gearing up for the 2025 season, with a focus on strengthening their starting rotation following the departure of key pitchers, including Sean Manaea. To retain Manaea, who showed significant improvement in the second half of the 2024 season, the Mets will likely need to offer a competitive multi-year contract. Experts suggest a standard offer would include three guaranteed seasons, plus a potential option for a fourth, particularly to accommodate Manaea’s evolving pitching style and recent performance. However, Manaea’s age and mixed track record present both challenges and opportunities for negotiation.

By the Numbers

• Manaea posted a .188 opposing batting average and a WHIP of 0.94 in the latter half of 2024.
• A 4-year contract valued at $78 million equates to an average annual value of approximately $20 million.

Yes, ButWhile Manaea’s recent performance has made him an attractive option, his age (turning 33 in 2025) and historical inconsistency may deter some teams from pursuing long-term deals, particularly due to the risk associated with securing a starting pitcher in that age bracket.

State of Play

• The Mets’ starting rotation is in need of significant rebuilding following multiple departures.
• Industry expectations indicate that retaining Manaea will require a contract that guarantees a fourth year.

What’s NextNegotiations are likely to intensify as the offseason progresses, with the Mets needing to balance a fair offer for Manaea against the potential financial implications and risks of a longer contract.

Bottom LineTo secure Sean Manaea’s talents for the 2025 season and beyond, the Mets must craft a negotiation strategy that factors in his recent success while also considering the inherent risks of committing to an older pitcher.